The Aerospace Corporation calls for a near term investment decision on Space-based Solar Power

Artist’s concept of a rectenna, a ground site that receives the microwave power transmission from a solar power satellite and converts it into electricity for a utility grid or other users. Credits: James A. Vedda and Karen L. Jones, The Aerospace Corporation

Space enthusiasts have been dreaming of the promise of space-based solar power ever since Peter Glaser first conceived of the idea in the 1960s and Gerald K. O’Neill leveraged the concept to popularize space settlements in his ground breaking book The High Frontier. But the costs have been preventatively high for many years and the technology has been stubbornly out of reach. Recent events and scientific advances have begun to change this situation. For example, launch providers are becoming more widely available and costs are coming down. Photovoltaic cell efficiency has dramatically improved since solar power satellites (SPS) were first conceived. On orbit robotic assembly, additive manufacturing and mass production is within reach. Finally, ISRU on the moon could provide access to materials outside the Earth’s gravity well dramatically reducing the cost of materials needed to build SPSs in space.

In a position paper released last month by The Aerospace Corporation’s Center for Space Policy and Strategy, recommendations are made for policy decisions by the U.S. government to make strategic investments in development of this space infrastructure, lest other countries beat us to the punch.

The authors of the paper, James A. Vedda and Karen L. Jones, say that “U.S. decisionmakers will have an opportunity during the next presidential term to establish the role of the United States in this potentially disruptive technology. If SPS can develop into a major component of orbital infrastructure, and someday contribute an additional source of renewable energy to users on Earth, the United States will want to be at the forefront of high-capacity power beaming in all its applications rather than become dependent on others for the technology and services they provide.”

NASA’s measurement plan for a lunar water reserve

Diagram depicting NASA’s Lunar Water ISRU Measurement Study (LWIMS). Credits: NASA

NASA just published a Technical Memorandum on its Lunar Water ISRU Measurement Study (LWIMS). The TM describes the establishment of a measurement plan for identification and characterization of a water reserve on the Moon. This program would support the Artemis program to achieve a sustainable lunar presence by 2028.

Three primary data inputs feed information into the system. First, predictive modeling provides a ‘water favorability’ index to map out locations on the Moon with water ice potential. This algorithm is fed data by orbital measurements providing information on a regional scale. It is critical that this orbital data is interpreted properly for water-favorable sites on the Moon. To ensure accuracy, lunar landers will take surface measurements in a series of three phases: mobile reconnaissance for validation of the predictive model, focused exploratory missions to verify water’s presence and final reserve mapping to inform an ISRU ice mining plant by 2028.

ESA envisions a space resource utilization program for the coming nascent space economy

Diagram depicting ESA’s program for space resource utilization such as harvesting lunar water and oxygen for rocket propellant and space manufacturing. Credits: Angeliki Kapoglou, ESA

A proposal submitted by ESA’s Angeliki Kapoglou, has been posted on the ESA website that defines a process for evaluating maturing technologies by the European space agency in cooperation with companies in the region. Called ESA Space Resources Utilisation Program, the proposal identifies the potential for a commercial market for water, oxygen and other products sourced from the Moon within the next decade as multiple space agencies plan for humans to return to the lunar surface. The program will position European countries and businesses to be major players in economic activities such as off-Earth propellant production, on-orbit refueling, autonomous in-space manufacturing using resources harvested from space, and robust construction on the lunar surface to support a sustained human presence.

The mission statement of the program is:

“Enable Europe through ESA to be well placed to benefit from the identification, acquisition, and development of space resources with important benefits for society on Earth. SRU will also provide an important reduction on the cost of other space missions…

We propose a series of small and rapid mission activities, to build capability and demonstrate key technologies for the utilisation of space resources. This will ensure that Europe is positioned for the Solar System gold rush that is coming and which will likely kick start with a cislunar economy with benefits for Earth. This constitutes a timely response to a rapidly evolving scenario for space resources.”

The program is expected to cost 100 million € and deliver key findings before the end of 2022.

Making oxygen from moondust with ROXY (and improving life on Earth)

Artist’s rendition of Airbus lunar lander with ROXY on board. Credits: Airbus

In a breakthrough experiment last month, a team led by Airbus Defence and Space (Friedrichshafen, Germany) has for the first time produced oxygen and other metals from simulated lunar soil with a proprietary process called Regolith to OXYgen and Metals Conversion, or ROXY. The revolutionary new process could be the core of an ISRU value chain on the moon, providing oxygen for habitats or rocket fuel, with added byproducts of metals and alloys as feedstock for additive manufacturing of building materials. This would significantly reduce the cost of settlements on the Moon as the construction materials could be fabricated in situ, without the need to be brought from Earth. Check out Airbus’ animation of ROXY here.

Airbus thinks that the ROXY reactor could have beneficial environmentally friendly applications on Earth as well:

“On Earth, ROXY opens a new pathway to drastically reduce the emissions of greenhouse gases that result from production of metals.” Since the process is essentially free of emissions “…these environmental impacts could be reduced, providing a significant contribution to the UN sustainability goals – another example of how space technologies can improve life on Earth”

Engineering analysis of a hybrid lunar inflatable structure

Illustration of a hybrid lunar inflatable structure. Credits: Rohith Dronadula

This month’s issue of Acta Astonautica features a rigorous engineering analysis of a hybrid lunar inflatable structure (HLIS), a habitat design that combines a collapsible rigid framework with an inflatable dome. The concept is based on a masters thesis by Rohith Dronadula under the direction of friend of SSP, Professor Haym Benaroya. Although the article is behind a paywall, SSP got permission to link a pdf of the article.

Dronadula took inspiration for the concept from the functionality of an umbrella. The design is simple in form yet robust in structural integrity. It can be autonomously launched from Earth and deployed through telepresence on the Moon. The structure is not only adaptable to most of the Moon’s habitable areas but also durable enough to withstand the extremes of lunar environments. The author recommends deployment within a lava tube and provides rigorous engineering calculations on the proposed materials and structures leading to a stable design with a safety factor of 6.

When humans go back to the moon in next few decades we will be able to survive and thrive in the harsh lunar environment by living in Dronadula HLISs.

Eta Space snags $27 million Tipping Point award to study space based cryogenic propellant depot technologies

Artist rendering of LOXSAT 1, a demonstrator satellite for a cryogenic oxygen fluid management system. Credits: Eta Space

A small Florida Space Coast start up founded by NASA employees called Eta Space was just awarded a 2020 NASA Space Technology Mission Directorate “Tipping Point” contract to develop the first low Earth orbit cryogenic propellant depot. Management of cryogenic fuels is a key technology for storing propellent in space, which will be a component of a transportation infrastructure supported by in situ resource utilization such as ice mining on the moon for processing into rocket fuel. A key focus of the work by Eta Space will be standardization of equipment interfaces allowing multiple customers to tap into storage capability on orbit.

Eta Space’s LOXSAT 1 mission concept will test a range of cryogenic fuel management processes in space over 9 months specific to liquid oxygen management. LOX is a common oxidizer used across multiple propellant systems by several launch providers and is the heaviest cryogenic fluid needed by most customers.

Intuitive Machine’s PRIME-1 ice mining drill to be delivered to the Moon by 2022

Illustration of Intuitive Machines’ Lunar Lander. Credits: Intuitive Machines

As part of the Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) initiative, NASA has selected Intuitive Machines to deliver ice harvesting equipment called Polar Resources Ice Mining Experiment (PRIME-1) to the Moon’s south pole. In a press release from yesterday, Intuitive stated that the instrument package includes a drill to excavate ice ladened regolith and a mass spectrometer to characterize the volatiles, the data from which will be used by the VIPER mission to follow shortly thereafter. Knowing how much water is available and how accessible it is will inform subsequent in situ resource utilization efforts needed for sustainable human outposts planned for later this decade.

An interdisciplinary approach to shaping our space future

Artist’s rendering of settlements on the Moon. Credits: Taylor Herring/Samsung via Futurism.com

A melding of multiple disciplines is required for creating a positive human space future that will enable space settlement. In addition to aerospace engineering, architecture and the traditional physical sciences we associate with space exploration, the fields of sociology, philosophy, art, space law and may others will be needed. A method for integrating these fields and coordinating them across the private sector, universities and government has been developed in The Interplanetary Initiative, a pan-university venture created at Arizona State University. The innovative research model is described in a paper in the September 2020 issue of New Space. The program turns students into team leaders and collaborators, equipping them with the skills and knowledge to solve problems anticipated to be encountered as humans expand out into the solar system.

Project RegoLight: Solar sintering lunar soil for 3D printed settlements on the Moon

RegoLight mobile printing head as implemented. Credits: RegoLight Consortium / Space Applications Services / International Astronautical Federation

Project RegoLight was an in situ resource utilization program funded by the European Commission to study automation of a process using solar energy to heat lunar soil to form building elements for a lunar settlement. The project ran from 2016 – 2018 and was intended to raise the technology readiness level from 3 to 5. The conclusions of the project were presented at the 69th International Astronautical Congress (IAC) held in Bremen, Germany in October 2018 and summarized in a report available on Academia.edu.

RegoLight had several primary objectives including automation of additive manufacturing of building elements under ambient conditions, fabrication of larger structures with a mobile printing head, demonstration of solar sintering under vacuum conditions, production of building elements using simulated lunar soil, material characterization of the building elements and other related processes in the context of a lunar settlement architecture. These activities would support plans for the Moon Village.

Conceptual view of an operational lunar base. Credits: RegoLight Consortium / LIQUIFER Systems Group / International Astronautical Federation

AIAA ASCENDxCo-Lab workshop identifies technology gaps for economically viable lunar settlements

Artist’s impression of a lunar settlement. Credit: ESA/Foster + Partners via universetoday.com

The 2020 virtual event sponsored by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics held in August brought together 200 space industry leaders from all over the world to discuss and respond to NASA’s ARTEMIS Plan. The event was summarized in a proceedings report that captured the group’s consensus on the technological and economic conditions needed for a sustained and economically viable lunar settlement. The attendees discussed the role of national space agencies, governments, and industry in addressing those conditions. The report defined a sustained lunar settlement as meeting the test of continuous survival and operation over time, and an economically viable settlement as one for which the long-term cost of maintenance is sustained by private capital.

When polled on the key technologies needed for a long term permanent presence on the Moon, the group identified the gaps in the chart below as those areas needing higher Technology Readiness Levels (TRL) to enable a permanent lunar settlement.

Technology areas needing further development. Credits: Jessica Todd et al.* / AIAA

The authors* then summarized the economic conditions identified at the workshop conducive to sustained lunar settlements, information needed to close the technology gaps and the roles of government space agencies as well as non-aerospace industries (e.g. healthcare, agriculture, food processing, utilities, mining and construction). _________________________________________________________________________________

* Authors of the ASCEND Ensuring Economically Viable Lunar Settlements Proceedings Report 2020 include:

Jessica Todd, Graduate Research Assistant, Aerospace Engineering in Autonomous Systems, Massachusetts Institute of Technology and the Woods Hole Oceanographic Research Institute
George Lordos, Ph.D. Candidate, Aeronautics and Astronautics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Becca Browder, Graduate Research Assistant, Aeronautics and Astronautics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Benjamin Martell, Graduate Research Assistant, Aeronautics and Astronautics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Cormac O’Neill, Graduate Research Assistant, Mechanical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology